How is a pope elected? 11 things about the conclave
The pope elected in conclave is a unique event. The conclave takes place very rarely (ten times between 1903 and 2013). It has special traditions, such as ‘white smoke’ and ‘Habemus papam’.
The election of a pope in a nutshell
The election of the pope takes place in conclave (which meets 15-20 days after the death or abdication of the pope)
The conclave is the meeting of cardinals (under 80 years of age) in the Sistine Chapel
The Sistine Chapel is located in Vatican City, where the supreme authority of the Roman Catholic Church resides
The conclave starts with a mass in the Sistine Chapel followed by a first round of voting
The cardinals are lodging in the Domus Sanctae Marthae in the Vatican, that we call the ‘Conclave Hotel’
From the second day onwards voting is held twice in the morning and twice in the afternoon (4 per day in total)
After each second round of voting the ballot papers are burned
In St. Peter’s Square, the smoke from the stove in the chapel indicates the score:
Black smoke: there is no new pope elected yet
White smoke: a candidate has received a 2/3 majority: he is the new pope
After about an hour after the white smoke, the new pope is presented from a balcony of St. Peter’s with the words “Habemus papam
How is a pope elected? In more detail
From the year 1059, the election of the pope has been reserved to the cardinals. They have the highest rank after the pope.
Since it has been a cardinals’ issue, elections could take a very long time. That culminated during the sede vacante (vacancy of the apostolic see) after the death of Clement IV in 1268. The cardinals met in Viterbo, in the place where the pope had died. None of the eighteen cardinals wanted to give in to each other. To urge them to hurry, the podestà (kind of mayor) of Viterbo had the roof removed and provided only water, bread and wine. That actually hardly deterred.
Feel free to read also our article about Viterbo and the papal palace overthere.
The new pope was elected in 1271 and assumed the name Gregory X. In 1274 he submitted a proposal to speed up the pope election introducing the conclave. The word come from medieval Latin. ‘Conclave’, in which the word clavis (key) is recognizable, means: (a room locked) with a key.
Today, the rules of conclave broadly correspond to the those of more than seven centuries ago. The differences include that the conclave is held in a fixed space -the Sistine Chapel, that the cardinals stay overnight in a proper accommodation (but only since 2005) and that only cardinals under 80 years have the right to elect the pope.
The conclave occurs fifteen to twenty days after the papacy becomes vacant (by death or abdication). That period is so long that the cardinals who live far away are enabled to come to Rome, among other things. This periode was often insufficient before the invention of the airplane. Cardinals from the United States have participated in the conclave only since 1958. Previous editions they missed because the boat would take too long.
Start of the Conclave
The first day of the conclave begins with the Mass ‘Pro eligendo papa’ (‘for the Pope’s election’). In the afternoon, the cardinals invoke the Holy Spirit by singing the hymn ‘Veni creator’ (‘Come Creator’). It is the belief of the participants that it is the Holy Spirit who inspires the name of the next pope to the electorate. But cardinals are also very realistic, often saying that the Spirit “writes straight on slanted lines,” or in other words that the spirit’s ways are inscrutable.
The Sistine Chapel, actually known only as a place without furniture, is furnished for the occasion. As many cherry wood seats are placed as there are electors (in 2013: 115 cardinals). Each seat is marked with the name and surname of each cardinal elector. The participants can cast their votes on twelve raw wood tables covered with beige cloth and burgundy satin. Six tables are placed on the right and six on the left, arranged in two rows at different levels.
The cardinals take an oath, first collectively, then personally (“I promise and swear…”). In short, they swear to abide by the rules of the conclave. Then the master of ceremonies utters the words “Extra omnes” (“everyone out”) after which only the cardinals remain in the chapel plus a few others who have an indispensable function. On the first day, one vote is taken. The following days include two rounds of voting in the morning and two in the afternoon. The voting procedure is worked out in detail.
To keep speed in reading, you can skip the next paragraphs and browse directly to the next heading (‘Acceptance of the election’) if you like.
First, the cardinals choose among themselves three scrutineers, who will count the votes, three revisors, who will check the scrutineers, and three infirmarii (who will collect the votes of the cardinals who are too ill to vote – that happens almost never). These nine cardinals are drawn by lot by the youngest cardinal-deacon.
After this the last non-cardinals, such as the master of ceremonies (if he is not a cardinal) and the secretary of the College of Cardinals are asked to leave the Sistine Chapel. Then the key goes into the lock: the conclave starts.
All cardinals in the chapel receive a ballot. On the rectangular ballot is printed “Eligo in summum pontificem” (“I choose as supreme pontifex”) and below that a continuous line on which the cardinal writes the name of the cardinal of his choice. When everyone has done so, each cardinal folds the ballot inward. After waiting his turn each cardinal walks with the ballot clearly visible to his colleagues to the altar that stands in front of Michelangelo’s fresco of the Last Judgement.
The ballot is placed on a gilded disc. The disc is then tilted so that the ballot falls into a deep oval bowl of gilded silver. This is the ballot box. When all the votes are cast, the bowl is covered with a lid and shaken. After that the ballots are counted. If the number of ballots does not match the number of cardinals entitled to vote, the election is immediately declared invalid. If the number is correct the next phase can start.
The first scrutineer opens the ballot and writes down the name. The second takes over the ballot and also writes down the name. The third reads the name written on the ballot aloud. This scrutineer pokes through the ballot with a needle and thread (exactly through the word ‘eligo’). This is done with each ballot, so that at the end of a vote you have a kind of paper chain. The revisors check the procedure and the result of the vote. The bundled voting ballots plus all other paper that is used, is put in a stove.
The stove stands on the other side of the Sistine Chapel. Since the 2005 conclave, the stove consists actually of two stoves. When the ballots are burned in one stove (right on the photo), it triggers an electronic, smoke-producing device outfitted on a second, more modern stove (left).
From both stoves a pipe comes together and passes through a window high in the chapel. On top of it is a chimney that can be seen from St. Peter’s Square. The idea is that people in St. Peter’s Square can ‘read’ the smoke.
If the cardinals haven’t figured it out yet, the camerlengo burns all the paper that gives off black smoke, meaning: we don’t have a pope yet. In that case, the second vote is held the next day. A maximum of four rounds of voting are held each day (except the first day).
After the fourth day of voting (i.e. after thirteen ballots), a day of rest is inserted, intended to achieve a result through prayer and deliberation. This is followed by seven votes and a day of rest each time until after fourteen days a new election key is used. Then whoever has half the voters plus one behind him becomes pope.
But in practice the cardinals settle things much faster. The (ten) conclaves of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries have lasted an average of 3.5 days or over seven votes. Benedict XVI (2005) was even elected in near record time: two days and four ballots. The fastest pope election was when Pius XII won in 1939 after three ballots.
Year of conclave
No. of electors
Acceptance of the election
When a candidate is backed by the required number of cardinals, the vice-dean has to ask him if he accepts the election as summum pontifex. “Accepto,” is the answer usually. “What do you want to be called?” is the next question. Popes take on a new name, much like a monk entering an order. This custom seems to have begun with John II (533-535) who found his proper name a bit all too pagan (Mercury, god of commerce).
Then the new pope is taken to what is known as the weeping room, a side room next to the Sistine Chapel. It is so named because the new pope can let his emotions run free after all the tension. In the weeping room, he is given his pontifical clothing.
Now the paper from the last ballot is placed into the stove. In the past, white smoke was obtained by adding dry straw. The white smoke is the sign that a new pope has been elected, and that the conclave has come to an end.
The stoves, the pipes and the chimney are only set up shortly before the conclave and are immediately disassembled after the end of the conclave.
Just under an hour later (forty minutes in 2005), the new pope is announced. The ceremony takes place on the central balcony of St. Peter’s. Heavy red drapes are pushed aside like curtains. The two balcony doors open. The protodecan comes out and speaks:
“Annuntio vobis gaudium magnum; habemus Papam, (“I proclaim to you a great joy: we have a pope”).
“Eminentissimum ac Reverendissimum Dominum (“and so is His Eminence the Highly Venerable Lord”)
“Dominum (first name) Sanctae Romanae Ecclesiae Cardinalem (surname).”
“Qui sibi nomen imposuit (name)” (“Who has taken the name…”)
Then the new pope steps forward onto the balcony of St. Peter’s. He wears pontifical white with a red shouldered robe over his shoulders. Around his neck is an embroidered stole. Then the new pope utters his first words. The first appearance of the Pole John Paul II was exemplary when, with great sensitivity to appease the mainly Roman crowd, he said, “I come from far away (…) corract me when I make mistakes in your, our language.” The grammatical error in this sentence amplified the effect of the message.